| Track | Song | Artist |
| 1 | Fairytale of New York | The Irish Tenors |
| 2 | Spirit of the Season | Alan Silvestri |
| 3 | It Came Upon a Midnight Clear | Sixpence None the Richer |
| 4 | Blue Christmas | Chris Isaak |
| 5 | Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas | Christina Aguilera |
| 6 | Baby It’s Cold Outside (feat. Natalie Cole) | James Taylor |
| 7 | Mary, Did You Know | Clay Aiken |
| 8 | The Angels Cried | Alan Jackson & Alison Krauss |
| 9 | Oh Holy Night | Kelly Clarkson |
| 10 | Happy Christmas (War Is Over) | Roch Voisine |
| 11 | Do You Hear What I Hear / The Little Drummer Boy | Vanessa Williams |
| 12 | Please Come Home for Christmas | Aaron Neville |
| 13 | Last Christmas (Studio Version) | Jimmy Eat World |
| 14 | Cool Yule | Louis Armstrong |
| 15 | Christmas Wrapping | The Waitresses |
| 16 | Just Put a Ribbon in Your Hair | Alan Jackson |
| 17 | River | James Taylor |
| 18 | What Are You Doing New Year’s Eve? | Ella Fitzgerald |
