| Track | Song | Artist |
| 1 | Joseph’s Lullaby | MercyMe |
| 2 | New Star Shining | Mark Wills |
| 3 | Angels We Have Heard On High | Steven Curtis Chapman |
| 4 | Prayer of Thanksgiving | Peter Breinholt |
| 5 | Song for a Winter’s Night | Sarah McLachlan |
| 6 | We Call It Christmas | Keb’ Mo’ |
| 7 | Christmas Time Is Here | Kenny Loggins |
| 8 | Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas | Diana Krall |
| 9 | Christmas Star | John Williams |
| 10 | O Come All Ye Faithful | Martha’s Trouble |
| 11 | Frosty the Snowman | Fiona Apple |
| 12 | O Christmas Tree | Martin Sexton |
| 13 | Please Come Home for Christmas | Eagles |
| 14 | Little Saint Nick | The Beach Boys |
| 15 | Sleigh Ride | The Ronettes |
| 16 | Christmastime (Oh Yeah) | Barenaked Ladies |
| 17 | Underneath the Mistletoe | Blondfire |
| 18 | Let It Snow! Let It Snow! Let It Snow! | Michael Bublé |
| 19 | Gabriel’s Message | Sting |
| 20 | What Child Is This (Greensleeves) | Matt Wertz |
| 21 | Still, Still, Still | Mormon Tabernacle Choir |
